Cara Eisinger, owner of Desert Dawn Insurance

Desert Dawn Insurance

Hi, I'm Cara

I built Desert Dawn Insurance around the way I actually work: one conversation at a time, no call center, no pressure. When you reach out, you're talking with me—your broker in Phoenix—about your Medicare, ACA, or private plan questions.

Born and raised in Arizona. Helping residents navigate Medicare, ACA, and private coverage since 2009.

My story & how I work
  • “We have had amazing service from Cara Eisinger for about 7 years. She has helped us with our insurance and Medicare choices for about 7 years. Helped us change to a different company to accommodate our doctors and prescriptions. Town and have never met her in person but highly recommend her”

    Patti Scanlon
  • “My husband and I highly recommend Cara Eisinger. She has helped us find the best healthcare insurance that fits our budget and medical needs over the last six years. Cara recently helped us transition to Medicare health insurance as we both turned 65. She is extremely knowledgeable with the competing insurance companies and keeps up to date on the changing policies and laws. Cara genuinely cares and takes her time to help you find the best health insurance that best fits your needs. We 100 percent recommend Cara! She is the best!”

    Lorie Edwards
  • “Cara was awesome to work with. She was extremely knowledgeable and helpful in helping us choose our health insurance. Would highly recommend working with her.”

    Sue Huber
  • “Cara has been helping my family with our insurance needs for over 10 years now. She has guided myself, my parents, and my grandparents to get the right coverage. Her kindness, compassion, and her expertise make her an absolute pleasure to work with. She genuinely cares about her clients and always goes above and beyond to provide the best support and advice. I couldn't recommend her more highly.”

    Aubrey McNeff
  • “I had such a wonderful experience with Cara at Desert Dawn Insurance. She is thoughtful, pleasant, and incredibly kind. Cara took the time to explain everything clearly and made the entire process easy and stress-free. She is very informative, professional, and truly the best at what she does. You can tell she genuinely cares about her clients. I highly recommend working with her! Thank You”

    Mary Cerda
  • “Cara is the ultimate expert on the complexities of Medicare plans, individual and family plans. Cara has counseled us through the maze of insurance options to tailor fit our needs. She makes the process easy and simple . Cara knows insurance and you will have the confidence and knowledge to make the right choices with Cara as your guide.”

    Lynn Dodd
  • “Working with Cara at Desert Dawn Insurance as our Insurance agent relieved our stress of resolving the complexities of Insurance policies. We discussed various types of medical insurance and decided on a Medicare Advantage Plan. It was perfect for our needs. She is highly qualified and answered our questions to determine the very best policy. We highly recommend Cara. She is honest and professional. We recommend her without reservation.”

    DMMT
  • “If you are lookimng for someone who can help you with your medicare needs, Cara is the best one to contact. She is the best consultant for her knowledge, dedication and patience. You will not be disapointed with her, a very friendly insurance agent for Anthem and its surrounding areas.”

    Y C
  • “I've always been glad to help me when i'm asking questions.I appreciate that and look forward to many years of service”

    Mel Pechart
  • “The Best ! Goes above and beyond to find the best deal for you!”

    Joanne Parkinson
  • “Cara is excellent- very knowledgeable about Medicare- Helped us with the right medical insurance for our secondary, and prescription Ins”

    Kathleen Donat

Logos are trademarks of their respective companies. Desert Dawn Insurance is an independent broker, not affiliated with or endorsed by any carrier.

2026 Health Insurance Marketplace Circle of Champions recognition badge

Health Insurance Marketplace

2026 Circle of Champions

I was named to the 2026 Health Insurance Marketplace Circle of Champions—among top-performing agents and brokers nationwide who helped 50 or more consumers actively enroll in Marketplace coverage with accurate, high-quality support.

About this recognition

CMS recognizes Marketplace-registered agents and brokers who meet updated performance standards focused on accuracy, consistency, and quality consumer support.

  • 50 or more active enrollments
  • Unresolved citizenship/immigration and income DMI rate below 4%
  • Medicaid denial attestation rate below 12%
  • 73% of total enrollments must be active enrollments
Local Agent on Medicare Agents Hub - Cara Eisinger (opens in new window)

Medicare Agents Hub

Local Medicare Agent

Listed on Medicare Agents Hub as a certified local Medicare insurance agent serving Arizona—find my profile, read reviews, and connect for plan guidance.

About this listing

Medicare Agents Hub helps people find licensed local Medicare insurance agents. My free listing includes my profile, service area, and a way to connect for personalized Medicare plan guidance.

Ready to talk with me?

Pick a time that works for you. I'll walk through Medicare, ACA, or private options at your pace.

Contact Cara